False Economy ran from 2010-2015. This site is no longer being updated, but the False Economy research team continue to report at Sentinel News.
Skip navigation


Exclusive: How councils pay millions for discredited lie detector tests on claimants

Guardian exclusiveIn the Guardian today, we have a story about 20 councils using or planning to use controversial lie detector tests to catch so-called "fradulent" benefits claimants, "despite the government dropping the technology because it was found to be not sufficiently reliable".

The Guardian reports:

"VRA [voice risk analysis] is supposed to detect signs of stress in a caller's voice by analysing short snippets of speech, and is still used in the insurance industry to catch fraudsters. Critics say the system is not powerful enough to distinguish cheats from honest callers.

False Economy, the trade union-funded campaign group that put in the freedom of information requests to more than 200 local authorities, told the Guardian: 'It says a lot about council outsourcing – and the benefits-bashing agenda – that this pseudo-scientific gimmick is now making its way in through the back door. Capita is a firm with a long rap sheet of expensive failure. Neither they nor their technological snake oil should be trusted.'"

Read the whole story in the Guardian.

Full list of councils

Used since 2011

Confirmed future use

Considering future use

Councils on the 'considering future use' list were generally in the process of procuring a company to run a Single Person Discount review with Capita's bid including VRA (or Capita had already been selected with VRA as an option).


(Abusive or off-topic comments will be deleted)



Play video: Why cuts are the wrong cure
VIDEO: Why cuts are the wrong cure