False Economy ran from 2010-2015. This site is no longer being updated, but the False Economy research team continue to report at Sentinel News.
Skip navigation


Video: claimants protest as DWP tries to overturn ruling on mental health work capability assessment

Location: UK » London » SW
Video: claimants protest as DWP tries to overturn ruling on mental health work capability assessment

Video below is from yesterday’s vigil outside the Royal Courts of Justice.

Inside the courts, the DWP was appealing a May Upper Tribunal decision which found that the Atos work capability assessment discriminated against people with mental health conditions. Several months ago, the DWP was granted leave to appeal this decision.

The original action against the DWP was brought by the Mental Health Resistance Network. Two claimants represented by the Public Law Project argued that Atos work capability assessments discriminated against people with mental health conditions. As the Public Law Project’s Ravi Low-Beer said here, the claimants wanted reasonable adjustments made to work capability assessments and the onus put on DWP to source medical evidence for ESA claimants who had mental health conditions at the start of their ESA claims.

The courts agreed with that direction – but the DWP wants the decision overturned. No matter that proposed changes may have improved things even slightly for people who must go through the appalling work capability process. No matter, even, that proposed changes may have improved things as far as the public purse goes – people found eligible for ESA from the start when they should be would not, obviously, need to take their case through the wildly oversubscribed and costly appeals process (which is not to forget that the government is about to make the appeals process even harder to access with its introduction of mandatory reconsideration for people wanting to appeal fit for work decisions).

Claimants talk about their experiences in the video. They also talk about the costs of the process – to them in an emotional sense and more generally, as a financial cost.

“I was managing my mental health really well until I got an ESA assessment,” one woman says. “After two weeks of distress, I ended up having to go into inpatient care, for three and a half weeks last year and two weeks this year. It cost the government and the NHS over £40k simply to to cover the cost of that crisis care. That crisis was manifest by ESA Atos and their assessment.” That, as we all know, is exactly the kind of maths and economics which makes perfect sense to Iain Duncan Smith and this government, and absolutely no sense whatsoever to anybody else.

Says Paula Peters:

“In 2011, I ended up in hospital for three months. I tried to take my own life for fear of waiting to be assessed under this cruel and callous system. I was hospitalised by the NHS for three months. I was held down and injected, because I have bipolar.”

She also makes this excellent point:

“If it can happen to us, it is going to happen to you. You can face your job cuts. You use the NHS - all of us use the NHS and they’re cutting back on all of that. I tell you something now. Any one of you can become sick. Any one of you can develop a devastating disability, or end up losing your job or livelihood like we all did and end up with devastating health problems.”



(Abusive or off-topic comments will be deleted)

Fixing Britain: Campaigns and events

UK campaigns map Isle of Man North West Northern Ireland West Midlands Scotland South West North East Wales East Midlands National/non-regional South East East London


Next events